New YorkShelter Island HeightsIconic Shelter Island Heights Waterview Victorian

Iconic Shelter Island Heights Waterview Victorian
37 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

 Get directions
Advertiser Logo
Penelope A Moore
Penelope A Moore
  • Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
Full Baths
Partial Bath
2,596 Sq Ft.
.25 Acres
Single Family Home
Property Type
Year Built
Web Id

About 37 Grand Avenue

Rental Registration #2022-S-0002 Since the turn of the century, this Victorian has greeted visitors coming from the North Ferry onto Shelter Island. It has a new life with a full-scale, high end restoration that imbues the best of yesterday with the amenities of today. Just past the picket fence and gate, and surrounded by perennial gardens, the rocking chair porch serves as an outdoor living room. Inside, the living room is welcoming, casual and yet elegant. The formal dining room is sun-filled with door to a kitchen that is what a country kitchen is all about, with a center island, restored range, custom styled cabinets, and a breakfast nook with adjacent powder room. The second floor can be accessed by either the front staircase or back staircase from the kitchen. There are 4 bedrooms as well as a well-designed office in the tower. The lower level of the house is finished with egress, with library, bedroom and full bathroom. The grounds offer privacy, hand-stacked stone with raised flower beds, and established trees. Within close proximity are the Shelter Island Heights beach club, tennis courts, golf course, and beautiful country lanes to explore. First offering to the rental market!


  • Finished Lower Level
  • Main Level Master Suite
  • Water View
Advertiser Logo

Saunders & Associates

Penelope A Moore
Penelope A Moore
  • Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
Contact Agent