Fully Appointed Sag Harbor Village

Fully Appointed Sag Harbor Village
156 Madison Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

 Get directions
Advertiser Logo
Jane Babcook
  • Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
Two Weeks
Full Baths
Half Baths
3,500 Sq Ft.
.48 Acres
Single Family Home
Property Type
Year Built
Web Id
Sag Harbor Union Free
School District

About 156 Madison Street

The "Bottle House", as it is known to the locals, is a luxurious Sag Harbor Village rental meticulously restored and renovated to today's standards. An extraordinary four-bedroom, four and one half bath residence with pool. Deemed a Village favorite, the home was originally built in the 1840s and thoroughly restored/updated in 2015. Exquisite finishes and moldings along with the finest craftsmanship and attention to detail exhibit the historic beauty of this home and combine with state-of-the art contemporary comforts and design. Stylish neutral furnishings, oak flooring, period woodwork throughout reflect the home's historic heritage. Dutch doors lead into well designed interior. The first-floor open concept living areas include a front parlor living room with fireplace, dining room with French doors opening to a bluestone porch and the patio beyond, and a gorgeous eat-in kitchen with vaulted ceiling, center island, Carrera marble countertops, dual sinks, ice-maker, pantry, Wolfe range, Sub-Zero refrigerator, breakfast nook, and beautiful custom cabinetry. A first-floor, sun-filled master suite offers a wall of windows with window seat, luxurious spa-like bath which opens out to the outdoors and walk-in closet. The second floor includes two charming guest rooms, one offering a gas burning fireplace. For movie night, head down to the lower level and enjoy the comfortable theatre. Completing this level are an additional guest room, substantial laundry room, and mirrored workout room with Precor AMT, bench, free weights and more. Outside, the beautifully landscaped grounds are a truly private oasis with multiple outdoor dining and lounging areas, a 50' heated gunite pool, block walls of granite originally found on the property as foundation of an icehouse, and stylish pool house with full bath and outdoor shower. Upper gardens feature a fire pit. Situated in a quiet neighborhood just moments from Sag Harbor Village's finest restaurants, shopping and marinas. Only 5+/- miles from Sagg Main Ocean Beach. After a day at the beach or after enjoying the Village nightlife this Hamptons rental is a perfect place to return and relax quietly within the serenely private grounds.


  • Pool
  • Main Level Master Suite